IRS Letter 2205-A Explained: What It Means for Crypto Holders and What to Do First

Picture the envelope: IRS return address, a form number in the corner, and a tax year you thought was finished. Inside, a letter says your return has been selected for examination. For crypto holders, your exchange CSVs are about to matter a lot.

Quick Answer: IRS Letter 2205-A is a notice that the IRS selected your tax return for an audit and outlines the items under review. It usually comes with a Form 4564 document request and a response deadline. It is not a bill. Don’t ignore it, and don’t send documents you haven’t reviewed yet. supermoney 

What is Letter 2205-A, exactly?

It’s an examination (audit) opening letter. Samples published by audit-defense firms show it paired with catalog number 37456E and a Form 4564 Information Document Request. The preliminary issues are typically named on the letter, for example Schedule C gross receipts or home mortgage interest. For crypto filers, the named items often relate to Form 8949 / Schedule D, or to income such as staking, mining or airdrops. taxaudit  supermoney 

What it is not: it’s not a CP2000 (an automated mismatch proposal) and not a balance-due notice. A CP2000 says “your numbers don’t match third-party data.” A 2205-A says “a human examiner is reviewing this return.” The difference matters because the response, the rights and the stakes are different.

Letter 2205-A CP2000 Balance-due notice (CP14 etc.) What it signals Return selected for examination Automated income/data mismatch You owe an amount Who handles it An assigned examiner Automated unit, then a caseworker Collections processing What it asks for Documents and/or an interview Agree, or disagree with evidence Pay or dispute Typical crypto trigger Gains/losses, income items, basis Missing or mismatched reported proceeds Previously assessed tax How to read the letter in 5 minutes

Go through these in order and write each one down:

Tax year(s) under examination. Only that year is open, though the examiner can ask about related years. Audit type. Examinations come as correspondence (by mail), office, or field audits. Pub. 3498-A covers exams by mail. Named issues. These are the items on your return the examiner wants substantiated. Form 4564 (Information Document Request). The checklist of what to send or bring. The response date and the examiner’s contact details. The date is on your letter. If you need more time, ask the named examiner before the date passes. Enclosures. Expect IRS publications on your rights and the exam process (Pub. 1, Pub. 556).

Verify the letter is real. The IRS opens exams by mail. A caller or texter claiming to be an auditor and demanding payment by gift card or crypto is a scam. Check the letter number, the examiner contact, and your IRS online account before replying to anything.

Why crypto returns get examined

Nobody outside the IRS can tell you why a specific return was picked. Plausible triggers include:

Digital-asset gains on Form 8949 that don’t line up with Form 1099-DA or other third-party reporting (1099-DA reporting began for 2025 transactions) Income that appears on exchange records but not on the return Large losses claimed with thin documentation The digital-asset question on Form 1040 answered “No” when records suggest otherwise Random or program-based selection

I won’t pretend one of these is “the reason.” The letter names the issues, and that list is your real starting point.

What an examiner will ask for on a crypto return

Expect a Form 4564 request that, in substance, wants you to prove three things: what you had, what it cost, and what you did with it.

Transaction history from every source. Exchange exports, on-chain wallet addresses, DeFi/bridge activity, and fiat bank statements showing deposits and withdrawals. cost basis support. Purchase records and dates. Since 2025, basis is tracked wallet-by-wallet under Rev. Proc. 2024-28 and Treas. Reg. §1.1012-1(j), so “pooled across all my accounts” is no longer a safe assumption for recent years. For earlier years, the method you used must match what you can document. Classification of events. Sale, swap, spend, gift, transfer between your own wallets (not a taxable event if truly your own), staking reward, airdrop. Crypto is property for federal tax purposes (Notice 2014-21). Reconciliation. Your records should tie to Form 8949 totals. A mismatch isn’t automatically fatal, but an unexplained one is.

The classic crypto-audit failure isn’t fraud. It’s an unmatched transfer: coins moved from Exchange A to a wallet, and the records can’t show the matching receipt. The examiner treats it as a disposal with zero basis unless you can prove otherwise. This is where audits get expensive.

Your first seven days Calendar the deadline and note it somewhere you’ll see daily. Make a full copy of the letter and enclosures. Don’t write on the originals. Don’t call the examiner yet. First work out what you’ll say. Pull the filed return and the exact Form 8949 / Schedule D lines for the named year. Export complete records from every exchange and wallet you used that year, including closed accounts. Exchanges purge data, so request old statements now. Reconcile before sending. Rebuild the year’s gains from raw records and compare to what you filed. Know your answer to “is the return right?” before the examiner asks. Decide on representation. A CPA, enrolled agent or tax attorney can handle the exam under Form 2848 (Power of Attorney), so you don’t have to speak with the examiner yourself. If your return involves large positions, DeFi, or possible underreporting, this is usually worth the money. Consult a professional about your own facts. This article is educational, not tax or legal advice. Send a response that’s complete, organized and indexed to the Form 4564 line items. Keep proof of delivery. Certified mail or the secure method the examiner names is standard. Mistakes that make audits worse Ignoring the deadline. Silence can lead to proposed changes made without your input. Volunteering extra years or accounts the request doesn’t cover. Sending raw data dumps. Examiners respond better to a reconciled, labeled package than a folder of 40 CSVs. Fixing the return mid-audit without advice. Whether to file an amended return or let the exam resolve is a judgment call for your representative. Guessing at basis. “Approximately” invites the zero-basis treatment. What happens after you respond

Outcomes generally fall into three buckets:

No change. The examiner accepts the return. Agreed changes. You accept adjustments and pay any tax and interest. Disagreed. You’ll typically receive a “30-day letter” (such as Letter 525 or 950) proposing changes with appeal rights. You can request an IRS Independent Office of Appeals review.

If adjustments are proposed, an accuracy-related penalty of 20% can apply under IRC §6662 in some cases. Reasonable-cause arguments depend on documentation and good-faith effort, so your records matter twice.

Statute of limitations context: the IRS generally has three years from filing to assess additional tax (IRC §6501(a)), extended to six years if more than 25% of gross income was omitted, with no limit in cases of fraud or non-filing. Because an exam on one year can reveal issues in adjacent years, treat the open year carefully.

How crypto tax fits in

Holdertax explains what IRS, HMRC, ATO and CRA notices mean and what they usually require. If you’re working through a 2205-A, the useful move is to reconcile your transaction history before you reply, so your answers match your records.

Does your exchange history have any gaps, such as closed accounts or old wallets, that you’d need to rebuild before a deadline? That’s the question to answer first. If useful, a follow-up guide on rebuilding missing cost basis could cover it.

Educational content only. Not tax, legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

crypto tax software.